Five Minute Facts  

Verification & Validation

Jose Adriani
Jose Mendez Adriani | Professor, Central University of Venezuela

Verification & Validation

Three different rotor kits with particular balancing equipments will be considered.

a. Balancing Equipment: model TM2, analyzer RS 3164, transducer PMG 48/S and stroboscope BG-No 707.00.020

Rotor Type: Centerhung

Balancing Method: Standard

Units:Vib: microns pk, Ang: deg; W: g;f=1800CPM

Data: in p. 174 of Reference 15 of Reference 1

System-Convention-Direction:Lead Phase-Rotating Scale-Contrary to Rotation

Used: on-line software in Reference 5

verification and validation of computational solutions

A>Data

N=  3.80000000000000E+001               d=      2.56000000000000E+002

F=   1.90000000000000E+001               e=       3.60000000000000E+001

Wtn=  7.95000000000000E+000          atn=   9.00000000000000E+001

N2=  3.10000000000000E+001             d2=    3.00000000000000E+002

F2=  3.70000000000000E+001              e2=     7.50000000000000E+001

Wtf=  7.95000000000000E+000           atf=     9.00000000000000E+001

N3=   1.70000000000000E+001            d3=     2.64000000000000E+002

F3=   3.10000000000000E+001             e3=     2.10000000000000E+001

Correction

Wn=  8.11252594400786E+000              an=     1.74367731945662E+002

Wf=   7.48493423362498E+000              af=      5.29374868807743E+001

rotating machinery - two plane balance

rotating machinery - two plane balance image 2

b. Balancing Equipment: rotor kit IRD Mechanalysis (model TM2 shown in the photograph), balancer Entek IRD 885, accelerometers IRD 970 and photocell Entek IRD 21000

Rotor Type: Overhung

Balancing Method: Standard

Units: Vib:microns pk-pk, Ang: deg; W: g;f=2613CPM

Data: in Reference 1

System-Convention-Direction:Lead Phase-Fixed Scale-Same of Rotation

Used: on-line software in Reference 5

on-line software

Table 1. Recorded data and corrections.

Commonto all methods
N=263.674 mm d=114° F=89.835 mm e=219°
WTL=3.0 g aTL=90°    
N2=111.720 mm d2=152° F2=63.184 mm e2=254°
Standard method
    WTR=3.0 g aTR=0°
N3*=285.676mm d3*=52° F3*=109.505mm e3*=117°
WL*=3.942 g aL*=98° WR*=1.397 g aR*=355°

verification & validation

verification and validation computer chart

c. Balancing Equipment:prototype, analyzer MicroVib II DSS, accelerometers P/N 1880 and photo tachometer MINI-BEAM P/N 1015 BANNER

Rotor Type: Overhung

Balancing Method: Effective

Units: Vib: in/s pk, Ang: deg; W: g; f=1617.54CPM

Data: in Reference 4

System-Convention-Direction: Lag Phase-Rotating Scale-Contrary to Rotation

Used: on-line software in Reference 5

Used: balance program in Reference 6 (Lead Phase-Fixed Scale-Same of Rotation)

balance program

recorded experimental data

rotating machinery verification and validation

rotating machinery verification and validation image 2

Units: Vib: in/s pk ,Ang: deg; W: g;f = 1619.42CPM

New Data:

recorded experimental data. Table 1

Lag Phase-Rotating Scale-Contrary to Rotation

System-Convention-Direction: Lag Phase-Rotating Scale-Contrary to Rotation

Used: invariance in Reference 3 and on-line software in Reference 5

Used: balance program in Reference 6 (Lead Phase-Fixed Scale-Same of Rotation)

balance program in Reference 6 (Lead Phase-Fixed Scale-Same of Rotation)

Proof of item (c) to check the computer program

Proof of item (c) to check the computer program

Conclusion: Comparable results were obtained for each case. Here, the verification of the computational solution is done by comparison with the standard solution. And, the validation of the computational model is done by comparison with the rotor kit.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

About the Author

Jose Adriani
Jose Mendez Adriani Professor, Central University of Venezuela

José Alberto Méndez-Adriani: Ing Mec (UCV, 1970), MSE Mech Eng (U of Michigan, 1973), FASP (MIT, 1980), ScD Mech Eng (City U of Los Angeles, California, 1989), QVA (IRD Mechanalysis, 1981), CMDB (Entek IRD, 1997), CTDPB (DSS, 2011); industrial practice in the assembly plant (GMC, 1976); Professor Emeritus of Mechanical Engineering and Postgraduate Tutor in Theoretical and Applied Mechanics at the Central University of Venezuela.